Umarex Single Action Army CO2 Air Pistol Review & Test
Well howdy folks we are back again for another test and review this time with the Umarex Single Action Army, aka the Peacemaker CO2 gas air pistol. The SAA was the very first air gun that we purchased for the Wild West Shooting Experience and therefore it is the most established and well used air pistol from the whole line up. It is certainly the one which excited us enough to jump into a completely new genre and embrace everything cowboy!
In this review Adam puts a couple of our well used examples through their paces and brings you some of the interesting tips, tricks and issues he has learnt along the way. You can dive right in and watch the video below or keep reading to discover our findings
Umarex Single Action Army Air Pistol – First Impressions
Umarex have done a wonderful job at presenting this pistol. The box is a wonderful tribute to the Old West with it giving the impression of wooden construction and the writing all in a shameless stereotypical font making it look printed. The Colt logo of course is proudly displayed in multiple locations as it is of course a licensed product.
When you pick the air pistol up for the first time, you will notice the weight straight away. They feel extremely solid in the hand and the grips index exceptionally well lining everything up, including the sights quickly and comfortably. You really could easily shoot this instinctively.
Build Quality, Design and Realistic Revolver Features
The Umarex Colt Peacemaker CO2 air pistol is a very solid all metal design with a hefty weight. The grips are plastic and hide the 12gram CO2 canister. There is a captive hex-key fitted to the inside of the removable grip for tightening the locking nut that pierces the gas cannister.
Umarex offer the Single Action Army in both a smooth bore and a rifled barrel, and at the time of writing you can purchase one in either a nickel or antiqued finish. Although they have offered a longer 7.5″ barrel in the past, the current offering is a 5.5″ version in keeping to the style of the Colt “Frontier Six-Shooter”
The sights are fixed without adjustment with a single post for the front and a v shaped grove cut into the top of the frame. Very authentic!
As per the originals, this is a single action revolver which means you have to cock the hammer for every single shot. Much like the originals the hammer has a half cock setting which allows the cylinder to rotate freely for loading and unloading.
Loading these is wonderfully realistic. Firstly you will need the shells/imitation bullets supplied with the pistol which hold your chosen ammo (either 4.5mm BBs or .177 pellets). The smooth bore version is supplied with brass coloured shells suitable for BBs whereas the rifled one is supplied with silver versions suitable for pellets.
Very much like the Barra we reviewed previously, you press the projectile into the back of the shell. Then with the pistol in the half cock setting, and with the loading gate open, you can drop the loaded shells in one by one. Once all 6 are loaded you should fully cock and decock the pistol before shooting for reasons discussed in the video.
Shooting Test – How Does the Umarex Single Action Army Perform?
Umarex claim that the SAA Peacemaker will get 120 shots from one full CO2 and having used these continuously in all weathers, we can confirm this to be completely true, and in fact spot on. Not 119, not 121, but 120 full powered shots every time equating to 20 reloads.
The accuracy of the Umarex SAA is quite reasonable considering that it is a plinker and not a target pistol. Having shot it at countless outlaw tin cans and knock down targets we have never had a reason to complain. Despite that it certainly is interesting to finally put it up against some paper targets and see how well it does.
Accuracy Test – How Accurate Is the Umarex CO2 Revolver?
We decided to test the accuracy of both the smooth and rifled barrel versions. With the BB gun being currently sold for as low as £160 and the rifled equivalent available for as low as £200, we felt it would be worth seeing if the latter is worth the extra £40 or if that money is better spent on ammunition (or Wild West costumes).
It is worth noting that both of these air pistols are used, heavily used in fact as part of our Experience Day line up. This isn’t to show you how good they are straight out of the box but to show you what they will be like in a few years of continuous use.
Both pistols were fitted with new gas canisters and our testing started with the BB version, shooting from a rest using very standard 4.5mm steel BBs into the paper target at approximately 10 metres.
Shooting 12 shots into the target and aiming consistently at the 6 o’clock of the black 7 ring, the results were quite pleasing considering BBs are not known for their accuracy. With most shots landing within a central zone this in itself shows that the pistol is more than suitable for any backyard plinking you might have in stall for it.
Although the BB version is supplied with the brass shells, it will also happily shoot pellets too if you load it with the silver shells. Why would you want to shoot pellets instead of BBs? Well although BB’s are certainly the cheaper and more cost effective option, they do bounce a lot when hitting anything hard so if you don’t have a way of stopping ricochets, your windows will no doubt thank you for shooting pellets. Likewise you can expect more accuracy with pellets even with the lack of rifling.
On that basis it was certainly worth testing the BB version with some .177 Exite “Hammer” pellets. Shooting the same number, at the same distance with the same point of aim, pellets showed a marked improvement with a nice vertical group around and under the point of aim.
Is the rifled saa barrel better than the smooth bore?
Next up was the rifled barrel version of the Umarex Peacemaker. We had high hopes for this one, it is of course carries a higher price tag and the spin of the rifling should surely give better results in so far as grouping. Again repeating the same shots aiming at the same point we answered the question.
So is the rifled version better? In a word, no. Or at least not with our findings at least. As you can see the from the image below the spread was larger and favouring the left hand side. The positives are that there’s more shots landing around or in line with the point of aim but I think generally everyone would expect a tighter group from a better quality barrel.
Concerned it could have been user error, this was repeated a second time and the results were arguably worse despite a nice little tight group at the base of the target.
Clearly this looks like a win for the BB smooth bore version. It is worth considering that a few factors can make a difference and with more time it is possible that we could get better results. Pellet choice certainly can be one of those factors, we are after all using the cheaper option suitable for plinking rather than target practice. The other factor could absolutely be age and wear on the barrel. It might be worth repeating with a new one if/when we get another.
And finally just for fun, we tried the long 7.5″ rifled barrel. This version of the Umarex SAA isn’t currently available in the line up but can sometimes be found on the second hand market. However a longer barrel should give better results and in this case it certainly did. Although shooting low and to the right, the group was excellent and exactly how we would have expected it to be. A shame it wasn’t centred but again different pellets may give better results and the worst case scenario means aiming more to the left. It at least gives a decent consistent group to work with.
Is the Umarex Single Action Army CO2 Air Pistol Worth Buying?
Absolutely it is! Considering the use that our examples have had, both actively on experiences and in addition “have a go” type use at a number of festivals, it is in many ways amazing that these are still shooting strong. It is a real testament to their build quality.
The look and feel will satisfy any Western fan and will look just as fine on display as they will in your hand. Personally we would recommend the nickel version over the antique finish for reasons mentioned in the video though both look fantastic in person.
Of course it’s probably quite obvious that with the results we achieved, it is easy to say that the Umarex Single Action Army BB gun (smooth bore) is probably the way to go. It certainly gave us the best results plus you have the versatility of shooting either BBs or pellets as well. Save the extra £40 and invest that into gas, ammo or maybe a leather holster!
Final Verdict – My Umarex Single Action Army Review
A fantastic, well made, durable and great looking pistol. it’s probably the closest to the real thing that the average person in the UK can enjoy and no doubt will delight any western movie, Red Dead Redemption or history fan alike.